Australian court rules an AI can be considered an inventor on patent filings

An Australian Court has decided that an artificial intelligence can be recognised as an inventor in a patent submission. In a case brought by Stephen Thaler, who has filed and lost similar cases in other jurisdictions, Australia’s Federal Court last…

An Australian Court has decided that an artificial intelligence can be recognised as an inventor in a patent submission.

In a case brought by Stephen Thaler, who has filed and lost similar cases in other jurisdictions, Australia’s Federal Court last month heard and decided that the nation’s Commissioner of Patents erred when deciding that an AI can’t be considered an inventor.

Justice Beach reached that conclusion because nothing in Australia law says the applicant for a patent must be human. As Beach’s judgement puts it: “… in my view an artificial intelligence system can be an inventor for the purposes of the Act. “First, an inventor is an agent noun; an agent can be a person or thing that invents. Second, so to hold reflects the reality in terms of many otherwise patentable inventions where it cannot sensibly be said that a human is the inventor. Third, nothing in the Act dictates the contrary conclusion.” The Justice also worried that the Commissioner of Patents’ logic in rejecting Thaler’s patent submissions was faulty. “On the Commissioner’s logic, if you had a patentable invention but no human inventor, you could not apply for a patent,” the judgement states. “Nothing in the Act justifies such a result.” Justice Beach therefore sent Thaler’s applications back to the Commissioner of Patents, with instructions to re-consider the reasons for their rejection. Thaler has filed patent applications around the world in the name of DABUS – a Device for the Autonomous Boot-strapping of Unified Sentience. Among the items DABUS has invented are a food container and a light-emitting beacon. The UK, USA and European Union have not chosen to adopt similar logic – and indeed the USA specifies that inventors must be human. However DABUS was granted a patent in South Africa last week, for its food container. Cloudflare offers $100,000 for prior art to nuke networking patents a troll has accused it of ripping off Apple on the hook for another $503m in decade-long VirnetX patent rip-off legal marathon Oracle accused of eating software maker’s lunch with hostile hiring, trade secret theft Australian intellectual property lawyer Mark Summerfield has strongly criticised Justice Beach’s decision on grounds that it could produce junk patents. “Just because patents are (or, at least, can be) good, it does not follow that more patents, generated in more ways, by more entities, must be better,” he wrote on his Patentology blog. “I do not consider the decision … to serve Australia’s interests,” Summerfield added. “I think that it represents a form of judicial activism that results in the development of policy – in this case, the important matter of who, or what, can form the basis for the grant of a patent monopoly enforceable against the public at large – from the bench.” Speaking to Guardian Australia, Summerfield raised the prospect of a flood of patents being awarded to machine-generated inventions, creating so many patents that other innovation becomes impossible. On his blog, Summerfield suggested “it may be perfectly reasonable to exclude those inventions that have not been devised by a human inventor. “It all depends upon what types of activity you wish to incentivise through the patent system. “If you want to promote the advancement of human ingenuity, while offering lesser (or no) rewards for automated innovation, then it is perfectly sound policy to deny patents on machine-made inventions.” Summerfield wrote that he hopes Australia’s patent authorities appeal – and win – because Justice Beach’s decision is “neither as clever nor as progressive as the judge appears to believe.” ® Similar topics MORE Ai Corrections Send us news Other stories you might like Huawei to America: You’re not taking cyber-security seriously until you let China vouch for us Slams Biden’s Executive Order on improving infosec, calls for multilateral trust framework Simon Sharwood, APAC Editor Mon 2 Aug 2021 // 06:15 UTC Huawei has decided to school America on cyber-security, and its lesson is to co-operate with China so its vendors – including Huawei – can be trusted around the world. A post from Huawei’s CSO for the USA, Andy Purdy, rates President Biden’s sweeping May 2021 Executive Order on Improving the Nation’s Cybersecurity as “the bare minimum that companies should be doing”. Purdy, a former White House adviser on cyber security, makes some decent points – especially when pointing out that the Executive Order is only binding on federal agencies and their private sector suppliers. Continue reading Zoom agrees to pay subscribers $25 to put its security SNAFUs behind it Zoombombing class action offers US$85m in payments, meaning even free accounts get a few bucks Laura Dobberstein Mon 2 Aug 2021 // 05:29 UTC US-based Zoom users may have a little cash coming their way after the video meeting outfit lodged a preliminary settlement in a class action related to some of its less-than-brilliant security and data protection practices. The settlement was filed Saturday in an attempt to end a class action that alleged Zoom indulged in unlawful activities – including misrepresenting its end-to-end encryption capabilities and unauthorized transfer of personal data to third parties like Facebook, Google and LinkedIn – as well as implementing grossly inadequate security and privacy controls. The latter led to “Zoombombing” – a distinctly 2020 term describing the hijacking of Zoom meetings, typically to display offensive material or otherwise disrupt people going about their business. Continue reading AWS adds browser access to its cloudy WorkSpaces desktops – but not for Linux Microsoft’s Windows 365 will do much the same when it launches Simon Sharwood, APAC Editor Mon 2 Aug 2021 // 04:31 UTC Amazon Web Services has stolen a march on Microsoft’s cloud desktop plans by adding browser access to its WorkSpaces desktop-as-a-service offering. Browser access will only work for WorkSpaces running Windows. Linux users are out in the cold and AWS hasn’t said when or if penguin-powered desktops will get to play. The service uses Amazon’s WorkSpaces Streaming Protocol (WSP), which doesn’t allow use of graphics-intensive instance types. AWS customers that run WorkSpaces from the Asia Pacific (Mumbai) and GovCloud (US-West) Regions also need not apply. For the rest of us, the service means browsers are now approved clients for an AWS WorkSpace – but not without complications. WorkSpaces set up to stream over the PCoIP protocol will work in Chrome or Firefox. WSP WorkSpaces can use any Chromium-based browser. Continue reading Wanna use your Nvidia GPU for acceleration but put off by CUDA? OpenAI has a Python-based alternative Plus: Software-detected gunshot withdrawn as evidence from trial Katyanna Quach Mon 2 Aug 2021 // 03:35 UTC In brief If you’ve always wanted to program your Nvidia GPU to accelerate machine learning, image processing, and other workloads, but find Nv’s CUDA too daunting or too much of a faff to learn, you’re in luck. OpenAI late last month released Triton, a Python-based environment that tries to help developers write and compile code to run on your Nvidia GPU much more easily without having to grapple with CUDA. The San Francisco upstart has been using Triton to optimize their software so that their machine-learning algorithms run more efficiently on specialized hardware. Building state-of-the-art models is costly, developers have to be able to train and tweak their performance quickly, which requires writing custom GPU kernels. Continue reading Jack Dorsey’s side hustle – payments outfit Square – acquires buy now pay later darling Afterpay for $29bn Plans to make partial payments for almost anything the new normal Simon Sharwood, APAC Editor Mon 2 Aug 2021 // 00:47 UTC Square, the credit card processing company run by Twitter founder Jack Dorsey, has announced plans to acquire Australian buy-now-pay-later (BNPL) outfit Afterpay for $29 billion. Afterpay offers shoppers the chance to acquire goods and services with four fortnightly payments. Merchants pay a commission for each Afterpay sale, often at higher rates than those charged by credit card companies. But consumers can use Afterpay free of charge if they pay on time. Even if punters miss a payment, the initial $10 late fee can be less than credit card interest on the same purchase. Also known as Clearpay in Europe, Afterpay is an Australian company and launched in 2015. A trading update [PDF] issued today reports it has 16.2 million active customers, 98,200 merchant members, revenue of A$925 million (US$679M) and facilitated $21.1 billion of sales in FY 2021. Continue reading Tech spec experts seek allies to tear down ISO standards paywall Open letter drafted against what’s seen as unjustified profiteering Thomas Claburn in San Francisco Sat 31 Jul 2021 // 13:06 UTC Many of the almost 24,000 technical standards maintained by the International Standards Organization (ISO) are subject to copyright restrictions and are not freely available. Two weeks ago, Jon Sneyers, senior image researcher at Cloudinary and co-chair of the JPEG XL (ISO/IEC 18181) adhoc group, invited fellow technical experts to collaborate on an open letter urging the ISO to set its standards free. In an email to The Register, Sneyers explained that paywalled, copyrighted standards inhibit education and innovation. Continue reading Sysadmins: Why not simply verify there’s no backdoor in every program you install, and thus avoid any cyber-drama? Just ‘validate third-party code before using it’, says Euro body Gareth Corfield Sat 31 Jul 2021 // 07:14 UTC Half of publicly reported supply chain attacks were carried out by “well known APT groups”, according to an analysis by EU infosec agency ENISA, which warned such digital assaults need to drive “new protective methods.” Of the 24 supply-chain attacks studied by ENISA since January 2020, a dozen were attributed to APTs while 10 of them hadn’t been attributed to anyone at all in open-source reporting, the agency said. Juhan Lepassaar, ENISA’s exec director, said in a canned statement: “Due to the cascading effect of supply chain attacks, threat actors can cause widespread damage affecting businesses and their customers all at once. With good practices and coordinated actions at EU level, Member States will be able to reach a similar level of capabilities raising the common level of cybersecurity in the EU.” Continue reading Euro watchdog will try to extract $900m from Amazon for breaking data privacy laws You miss every shot you don’t take, we guess Thomas Claburn in San Francisco Fri 30 Jul 2021 // 22:33 UTC Amazon says a European Union privacy watchdog has mustered the temerity to demand a $885m fine for failing to comply with data privacy rules. “On July 16, 2021, the Luxembourg National Commission for Data Protection (CNPD) issued a decision against Amazon Europe Core S.à r.l. claiming that Amazon’s processing of personal data did not comply with the EU General Data Protection Regulation,” the web goliath said in a financial filing accompanying its Q2 2021 earnings report [PDF] on Thursday. “The decision imposes a fine of €746m [$885m] and corresponding practice revisions.” Continue reading Russia says software malfunction caused Nauka module to unexpectedly fire thrusters, tilt space station You call this a glitch? Chris Williams, Editor in Chief Fri 30 Jul 2021 // 20:09 UTC Russia said a “software failure” caused its Nauka module to suddenly and unexpectedly fire its thrusters after docking with the International Space Station this week. The engine burn caused the orbiting lab to tilt 45 degrees at a rate of about half a degree a second. The station automatically fired thrusters on its Russian Zvezda module and an attached Progress cargo craft to compensate, creating a brief tug of war between the module and the station. After about an hour, officials were able to regain attitude control. Commands were sent to Nauka to not only shut off the thrusters but ensure they cannot inadvertently fire again. NASA insisted the seven astronauts onboard the ISS were not harmed nor in any real peril during the undesirable thruster burn, which started at 1634 UTC on Thursday. Continue reading HP Inc slurps Teradici to get better at delivering remote PCs Apparently quite a few people haven’t been in the office as much lately Simon Sharwood, APAC Editor Fri 30 Jul 2021 // 18:04 UTC HP Inc has acquired remote PC specialist Teradici. Teradici’s best trick is PC-over-IP (PCoIP), software that makes PCs remotely accessible by streaming whatever would be on their screens. The company’s approach means that no data moves over networks – just bitmaps. The tech is well regarded and can point to one ringing endorsement as a presence behind Amazon Web Services’ “Workstations” desktop-as-a-service product. Continue reading ‘$6 in every $10’ spent on cloud infrastructure is with AWS, Microsoft, or Google Fewer and fewer orgs want to run their own data centre Paul Kunert Fri 30 Jul 2021 // 17:16 UTC Spending on cloud infrastructure services shot up by more than a third again as workload migration and cloud native applications development sped up, according to the latest research from Canalys. After AWS filed its latest set of quarterly figures last night, analysts at the channel focused consultancy confirmed that some $47bn was forked out by biz customers on infrastructure-as-a-service (IaaS) in calendar Q2, up 36 per cent year-on-year. The top three cloud providers accounted for 61 per cent of this total expenditure, said Canalys, and AWS was the frontrunner with a 31 per cent share of the spoils, or $14.57bn. Continue reading SITUATION PUBLISHING The Next Platform DevClass Blocks and Files Continuous Lifecycle London M-cubed The Register – Independent news and views for the tech community. Part of Situation Publishing SIGN UP TO OUR DAILY NEWSLETTER Subscribe Biting the hand that feeds IT © 1998–2021 Do not sell my personal information Cookies Privacy Ts&Cs